Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative by Follow Your Heart


Update! Though Vegan Gourmet Cheese is getting edged out by Follow Your Heart’s newer soy-free Slices & Blocks, it still has a loyal following and seems to still be regularly stocked at many natural food stores.

Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative by Follow Your Heart (Review) - Non-GMO Verified & made with Organic Soy

Vegan Gourmet Cheese alternative is soy-based, but it is non-GMO verified and made with over 70% organic ingredients, including organic soy. Thus far, we’ve trialed the two more traditional flavors, Cheddar and Mozzarella, but it’s also available in Monterey Jack and Nacho varieties.

Cheddar Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative

The Cheddar version of Vegan Gourmet Cheese was a bit oily in the package, slightly off-putting, but I quickly got past it. For an initial test, I sliced off a small chunk for a “raw” taste. The texture was solid and slice-able, but softer than regular cheddar. I was impressed with the flavor, which was very notably cheddar, but milder than its namesake. As someone who never really liked the texture nor pungent taste of cheddar very much, these differences were actually welcomed.

Vegan Gourmet’s claim to fame is that it actually melts. Though I have read mixed reviews on this.  Many people show beautiful pictures of the bubbling cheese alternative, while others are only able to coax it into softening. Determined to see it for my own eyes, I got out the cheese shredder and cranked up the oven.  I immediately discovered a huge benefit of the softer texture … Vegan Gourmet Cheese alternative is very easy to shred! Beautifully thick slivers rolled off my grater with nary an ounce of muscle, completing half the package in less than thirty seconds.

Vegan Gourmet Cheddar "Cheese"

My first medium of choice was the Polenta Casserole from Eat, Drink, & Be Vegan. As for the melting, well, it didn’t really happen. The Vegan Gourmet Cheese alternative softened, and made for an excellent meal. Really, no complaints from my family … but I was unable to coax it into a creamy, gooey topping.

I used the remaining cheddar atop our spaghetti one night to add a cheesy punch to the marinara. Not attesting to the melt, but rather flavor, my husband proclaimed the meal excellent. Neither of us felt that the Vegan Gourmet Cheese was really the star, but it served as a nice accent.

My friend Barb, who has two children with multiple food allergies (including dairy) decided to give Vegan Gourmet Cheese a trial with her family, too. She shared the following feedback:

I decided to try the Cheddar Cheese flavor in my baked macaroni and cheese; it turned out fantastic. Great news for anyone looking for a cheese alternative that really melts. The best part is you can freeze it, to prevent spoilage.

Mozzarella Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative

I was pleased to find a nice smooth block within the package, not a bit greasy. My initial taste of this Vegan Gourmet Cheese block was a bit of a surprise. The flavor of the mozzarella was good, but quite mild and a little bit underwhelming.

Regardless, I went for the gold on testing. Following the package instructions to the T, I was determined to make Vegan Gourmet Cheese alternative melt atop pizza. I followed their high heat instructions, but alas, my shreds merely softened, and began to brown at the tips, without achieving the full melt. Not ready to give up, I slid the pizza into the broiler for one minute. This did it … at least a bit. The crust was a touch overdone after this escapade, but luckily not burnt.

Vegan Gourmet Mozzarella "Cheese"

It really was a wonderful treat to have a pizza with “cheese,” but next time I would try a cheddar / mozzarella blend. The mozzarella seemed to be overpowered by the crust and sauce. Perhaps it might fair better with a mild pesto? On the contrary though, my friend Barb did think the Mozzarella held its own:

I came home, and made the children bagel pizzas topped with Vegan Gourmet Cheese for lunch. To my surprise the mozzarella was soft, easy to shred and it ACTUALLY MELTED, just like the package stated. Then came the real test, I took a bite of the pizza, and it tasted really really good! Honestly, this cheese alternative possessed all of the wonderful flavors and textures of regular cheese once melted. It was great!

While I cannot yet proclaim that the perfect cheese alternative has been developed, Vegan Gourmet Cheese is pretty tasty … and I am still in love with its shredability.  I do plan on trying it again, especially to give their other two flavors, Nacho and Monterey Jack, a test run.

From reading around, I have found that each person seems to have their own “favorite” when it comes to cheese alternatives, as the few brands on the market are each so different.  That being said … if you haven’t trialed Vegan Gourmet as of yet, then it is definitely worth a taste.


Certifications: Follow Your Heart’s Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative is Non-GMO Verified.

Dietary Notes: By ingredients, Follow Your Heart’s Vegan Gourmet Cheese Alternative is dairy-free / non-dairy, egg-free, gluten-free, grain-free, nut-free, peanut-free, vegan / plant-based, and vegetarian. Nonetheless, check with the company on their manufacturing processes for all varieties if potential allergen cross-contamination is an issue for you. Processes and labeling are subject to change at any time for any company / product.

For More Product Information: Visit the Follow Your Heart website at

About Author

Alisa is the founder of, Senior Editor for Allergic Living magazine, and author of the best-selling dairy-free book, Go Dairy Free: The Guide and Cookbook for Milk Allergies, Lactose Intolerance, and Casein-Free Living. Alisa is also a professional recipe creator and product ambassador for the natural food industry.


  1. FYH Cheddar Shreds was so disgusting. My family is newly Vegan and we all hated the taste of the cheese. We will be trying Daiya next we are hoping it tastes nothing like this.. I’ve heard many vegetarians are vegetarian instead of Vegan because they can not give up real cheese.

  2. Daiya in bulk form caused temporary impotence due to the effect of the oil content.
    My medical clairvoyant recommends Vegan Gourmet now.

  3. We use the mozzarella cheese to make an individual size pizza for my daughter. We have that the best way to get the cheese to melt is to cover the pizza with a cake pan and heat it for about 15-18 minutes at 450 degrees. We take it out of the oven and let it set for a few minutes before cutting it. Otherwise, the cheese is too runny.

  4. Thanks for posting this, it was an interesting read! We have tried Daiya and Vegan Gourmet… so far my 9 year old son would rather have no cheese than either of these, so I am still looking 🙁

Leave A Reply