The Best Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream You Can Buy …

4

I do appreciate flavor creativity, I really do. But like many of you, I often just want simple dairy-free vanilla ice cream. Fortunately, there are dozens of dairy-free vanilla ice cream brands available for your simple cravings and à la mode needs. And we’re here to help you find the best one for you! We bought every vegan and dairy-free vanilla ice cream variety that we could find our local area and had a taste test with members of our household – two dairy-free and two dairy consumers. Here are the results!

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best! All Vegan, Mostly Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, and More ...

And the Best Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream You Can Buy Is …

We were genuinely surprised by how different each brand tasted. Even pints made with the same base had their own distinct flavor and mouthfeel. That means there really is something for everyone. But this was the hands-down winner in our taste tests.

Ripple Vanilla

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!It really was no contest. We all agreed that Ripple had nailed dairy-free vanilla ice cream. Our resident teen said it tasted like custard, and we all agreed it had a French vanilla vibe. The flavor was sweet, but very well rounded and balanced with the right amount of vanilla. It also had a smooth, creamy, lightly whipped, and easy-to-scoop consistency that rivaled dairy ice cream. Everyone went back for seconds, and agreed it was delicious with nothing added, but also perfect for a la mode. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

How the Other Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Brands Ranked

I’ve listed them in order, from our top runner up, down to the pint we’ll definitely pass on. But I’ve also included tasting notes. Because, what didn’t suit us, might be your perfect plain Jane vanilla!

So Delicious Very Vanilla Cashewmilk

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!All of the adults agreed that this flavor really was delicious. But despite the name, it doesn’t taste like vanilla ice cream. They pretty much nailed the rich, sweet flavor of butter pecan. The teen in our group thought it tasted like peanut butter and chocolate together, which she isn’t a fan of (yes, it’s true). Nonetheless, she agreed that the consistency was quite good and the sweetness was right. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

Alden’s Organic Dairy Free Vanilla Bean

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!Our resident teen and her mom said it tasted a little fruity, almost like Fruit Loops. It is a “fruitier” vanilla that gives way to a sweet, purely dessert aftertaste. It seemed cooler and more refreshing than many of the others, and had a lightly creamy consistency. We all thought it would work very well à la mode, with toppings, or in dairy-free ice cream sandwiches. As a stand-alone vanilla, we agreed it needed a little something to round out the flavor (a pinch of salt, perhaps?). Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

Archer Farms Non-Dairy Vanilla Bean

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!We were a bit divided on this brand at first. The dairy consumers immediately liked this brand and gave it a thumbs up. (A dairy consumer that wasn’t in our taste tests even snuck this pint from the freezer and finished it!) The dairy-free consumers said it was a bit sugary, unrefined, and not as smooth as we would like. But it was still a decent contender that we would consider repurchasing. Everyone agreed it had a notable light almond flavor, and was definitely a little “dairy free” in taste. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

Elmhurst Vanilla Soft Serve Mix

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!“It tastes like the milk leftover after cereal,” said our teen taster. She totally nailed it. Perhaps it’s the oat base, but this really does have that comforting, sweet taste of milk saturated with sweet grains. It works much better as soft serve than churned and hard packed (we tried both), and has a light, frosty-like mouthfeel. I recommend keeping this one on hand along with a Zoku bowl in the freezer for single-serve needs. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

Oatly Vanilla

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!We found the flavor of this pint a little more difficult to pinpoint. Our resident teen thought it tasted a bit like Oreo filling, but without the shortening aftertaste. Her mom thought it was just creamy enough and had a good general flavor, but she could definitely taste the oat base. Tony thought it was flat in flavor and wasn’t impressed. I thought it was a bit too “oaty” and agreed with Tony that it was flat in flavor. We all agreed that it lacked vanilla flavor and had an underwhelming, rather nonexistent aftertaste. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconutmilk

So Delicious Coconut Milk Ice Cream Reviews and Info - Dairy-Free, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, Vegan. Pictured: Vanilla BeanI honestly expected this brand to be a top pick, but it was a little overwhelming in a few ways. The flavor was very coconut forward with hints of vanilla that only a couple of us could detect. The consistency was quite creamy, but to our dairy eaters, it was so whipped that it was almost like whipped topping. I had to agree, the latest So Delicious formula is beginning to taste more like CocoWhip. All of this is okay for coconut fans, which some of us are. But the aftertaste leaves a shortening-like residue that was quite unappealing. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

365 Vanilla Bean Almondmilk

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test - Get the Scoop on Which Ones Ranked Best!This brand confused us, which was easy to see by all of the puzzled looks. I thought it tasted like coffee, which I don’t like. There were votes that it was very almond-y, but a little disjointed. One comment was that it was “vanilla in parts.” Another said it starts out vanilla, but then melts into “some other flavor.” We couldn’t say it was a strong dislike, but Whole Foods brand wasn’t met with a great deal of love, either. We all agreed not to buy it again. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

Coconut Bliss Madagascan Vanilla Bean

Coconut Bliss Ice Cream - Review and Information on this popular Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert. Clean ingredients, vegan, and more ...(Note: In our stores, the package was pink – see my photo above.) Raw foodists might like this coconut ice cream, but it wasn’t for any of us. Tony said it tasted like young Thai coconut, and nothing else. It was very coconut-heavy in taste and texture. The consistency was dense, more buttery than creamy, and slightly gritty. The flavor was slightly fruity and only a little sweet. Our resident teen even said it was a bit tangy. To our taste buds, this didn’t quite qualify as dessert, and it was quite a detour from vanilla ice cream. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

No Sugar Added So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconutmilk

So Delicious No Sugar Added Dairy-Free Ice Cream / Frozen Dessert - Reviews and Information - Dairy-Free, Soy-Free, VeganNo, just no. We all took a hard pass on a second bite of this ice cream. This used to be a fan favorite for dairy-free, sugar-free ice cream. But the new formula just isn’t it. It flaked like coconut, tasted like coconut, was a bit gritty, and had an unpleasant sweetener after taste. It received a strong thumbs down from our whole tasting team. Get the: Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, and More Consumer Reviews.

More Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Creams

I’ve included this list of other dairy-free vanilla ice cream brands sold nationwide in the U.S. that we didn’t have available. You can click on each for Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, Availability, and Reviews from other people like you.

Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream Recipes

Yes, you can easily churn your own dairy-free vanilla ice cream at home! Here are a couple of our favorite recipes.

Vanilla Bliss Dairy-Free Ice Cream (can omit chocolate chips)

Dairy-Free Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Recipe (No Coconut!) - naturally gluten-free, nut-free, soy-free, and vegan

Classic Vanilla Coconut Ice Cream

Classic Vanilla Coconut Ice Cream Recipe (Dairy-free and Vegan). Easy (no cooking or pre-chilling) with several variations (Orange Sherbet, Stracciatella, Coconut, Ice Milk). Also soy-free and gluten-free.y-Free Easy

For More Dairy-Free Guidance & Recipes, Get Go Dairy Free!

Go Dairy Free - The Guide and Cookbook for Milk Allergies, Lactose Intolerance and Casein-Free Living

About Author

Alisa is the founder of GoDairyFree.org, Food Editor for Allergic Living magazine, and author of the best-selling dairy-free book, Go Dairy Free: The Guide and Cookbook for Milk Allergies, Lactose Intolerance, and Casein-Free Living, and the new cookbook, Eat Dairy Free: Your Essential Cookbook for Everyday Meals, Snacks, and Sweets. Alisa is also a professional recipe creator and product ambassador for the natural food industry.

4 Comments

  1. Trader Joe’s has a relatively new vanilla dairy free ice cream that is quite disappointing. My young teen who normally will scarf down anything sweet, especially ice cream, left it languishing in the freezer until I finally threw it out. He said it tasted like frozen frosting, and not in a good way. A few other people tried it and agreed.

  2. Vanilla really is the hardest flavor to nail. There’s no where to hide subpar ingredients in such a simple, clean flavor. My personal favorite might be Van Leeuwen’s, but it’s a tough call.

Leave A Reply