Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts are Ready-to-Bake in Organic and Gluten-Free

24

Do you need a last minute shortcut for those holiday pies? Or perhaps you’re looking for quick roll out pie dough for an easy dessert? Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts could be your solution. Their shells come in several dairy-free varieties, including organic wheat and certified gluten-free. And their roll out dough is perfect for making a top crust but can also be shaped for other recipe needs.

And unlike most other brands, Wholly Wholesome is very transparent with their ingredients and processes. Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts are made with just a handful of simple, non-hydrogenated, no funny-business ingredients. They also go the extra mile with certifications, boldly note top allergens, and even disclaim allergens in their factory (beyond the same line!).

Wholly Wholesome Crusts: Pie Shells - All Dairy-Free and Kosher Pareve, One Certified Gluten-Free Option

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Bake-at-Home Pie Shells)

I’ve reviewed Wholly Wholesome’s whole, frozen dairy-free pies before. But for DIY cooks or those like me who love this dairy-free, soy-free pumpkin pie filling, the Wholly Wholesome bake-at-home pie shells are worth considering.

Wholly Wholesome discontinued their shelf-stable crumb crusts, but their bake-at-home pie shells remain a grocery store staple. They come in 9-inch Traditional, Whole Wheat, Spelt, and Gluten-Free varieties. These premade conveniences are sold in the freezer section in two-packs, and are meant to be baked according to your recipe (pre-baked or filled and then baked).

Organic Traditional Pie Shells

This is a simple, classic pie crust. It bakes up light and flaky, according to the directions. My husband is a classic pie crust fan, and he gave it two thumbs up. This pie shell is also available in a smaller 6-inch variety.

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: organic wheat flour, organic palm oil, water, organic cane sugar, sea salt. contains: wheat. made in a facility that uses dairy products.

Nutrition (per 1/8th crust): 120 calories, 8g fat, 10g carbs, 0g fiber, 1g sugars, 1g protein.*

Organic Whole Wheat Pie Shells

I’m a true whole wheat fan. I love the nutty flavor whole grains impart, so I preferred this pie crust. It baked up perfectly, according to the directions, and was still flaky enough to win my husband’s approval.

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: organic whole spelt flour (wheat), organic palm oil, water, organic cane sugar, sea salt. contains: wheat. made in a facility that uses dairy products.

Nutrition (per 1/8th crust): 110 calories, 8g fat, 9g carbs, 2g fiber, 1g sugars, 2g protein.*

Organic Spelt Pie Shells

I haven’t found this crust yet!

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: organic whole wheat flour, organic palm oil, water, organic cane sugar, sea salt. contains: wheat. made in a facility that uses dairy products.

Nutrition (per 1/8th crust): 120 calories, 9g fat, 9g carbs, 1g fiber, 1g sugars, 2g protein.*

Gluten Free Pie Shells

Since gluten-free baked goods can be more finicky, I have a more detailed review for Wholly Wholesome Gluten-Free Pie Shells. I even took some photos when I used one to make a Chocolate-Peppermint Pudding Pie.

I really liked the flavor of the gluten-free Wholly Wholesome crusts – and I’m not typically a pie crust fan. My friend Caroline concurred that it was quite pleasant in flavor, mild, yet tasty on its own. They lacked the bitterness that so many savory gluten-free baked goods suffer with.

But there was just one big drawback – it doesn’t quite bake up. As you can see, the crust didn’t brown at all. In fact, I cooked it two minutes longer than recommended, and it was still a little doughy rather than flaky. Caroline was a bit turned off by this “undercooked” vibe. Though, I still found the crust too yummy to leave behind. Overall, she did agree with me that the flavor warranted a solid 4 stars, and that with a little extra cook time, it might meet her flakier expectations.

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: brown rice flour, water, organic palm fruit oil*, organic evaporated cane syrup, tapioca starch, potato starch, contains less than 2% of each of the following: sea salt, aluminum free baking powder (sodium acid pyrophosphate, baking soda, tapioca starch, monocalcium phosphate), guar gum.

Nutrition (per 1/16th crust): 100 calories, 5g fat, 12g carbs, 0g fiber, 2g sugars, 1g protein.*

Chocolate Peppermint Layer Pie with Gluten-Free Wholly Wholesome Crust and Dairy-Free Mori-Nu Pudding Mixes

Wholly Wholesome Organic Pie Dough (Roll Out & Bake)

In addition to the preformed pie shells, Wholly Wholesome offers pre-rolled pie dough that can be rolled on as a top pie crust, cut, or even shaped as needed. Their dough has slightly different ingredients from their pie shells to make it a bit more pliable for home cooks to use.

Organic Traditional Rolled Pie Dough

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: organic wheat flour, organic palm oil, water, organic cane syrup, sea salt, organic cane sugar, organic guar gum, organic rice flour. contains: wheat. made in a facility that uses dairy, egg, soy.

Nutrition (per 1/8th dough): 130 calories, 9g fat, 11g carbs, 0g fiber, 1g sugars, 1g protein.*

Organic Whole Wheat Rolled Pie Dough

Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough Information and Reviews - available in Organic Traditional, Organic Wheat, Organic Spelt, and Gluten-Free Varieties.Ingredients: organic wheat flour, organic palm oil, water, organic wheat flour, organic cane syrup, sea salt, organic cane sugar, organic guar gum. contains: wheat. made in a facility that uses dairy, egg, soy.

Nutrition (per 1/8th dough): 120 calories, 7g fat, 13g carbs, 2g fiber, 1g sugars, 1g protein.*

Chocolate Peppermint Layer Pie with Gluten-Free Wholly Wholesome Crust and Dairy-Free Mori-Nu Pudding Mixes

The Facts on Wholly Wholesome Crusts

Price: $6.49 per two-pack of crusts; $7.69 per 16-ounce roll out dough

Availability: Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough are sold frozen, near the frozen desserts and frozen fruit at grocers in the U.S. We’ve spotted them at Natural Grocers, Sprouts, Whole Foods, Albertsons stores, Publix, and Winn-Dixie.

Certifications: Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough are Certified Kosher Pareve. The gluten-free varieties are Certified Gluten-Free. The wheat-based varieties are Certified Organic.

Dietary Notes: By ingredients, Wholly Wholesome Pie Crusts (Shells) and Pie Dough are dairy-free / non-dairy, egg-free, nut-free, peanut-free, soy-free, vegan, and vegetarian. Select varieties are made in their gluten-free bakehouse.*

For More Product Information: Visit the Wholly Wholesome website at www.whollywholesome.com.

*Always read the ingredient and nutrition statement prior to consumption. Ingredients, processes, and labeling are subject to change at any time for any company or product. Contact the company to discuss their manufacturing processes if potential allergen cross-contamination is an issue for you. No food product can be guaranteed “safe” for every individual’s needs. You should never rely on ingredient and allergen statements alone if dealing with a severe food allergy. 

Average Reader Review

4.8
4.8 rating
4.8 out of 5 stars (based on 4 reviews)
Excellent75%
Very good25%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

Leave Your Rating & Review for This Product

What Others Are Saying ...

Easy as pie

5.0 rating
September 5, 2020

I have been disappointed with gluten free pie crusts in the past; not so with Wholly Gluten free pie crust. I had never seen the brand before; admittedly skeptical, I decided to take chance and buy them. I am so happy I did, these are the best gluten free crusts I have ever used. They were not soggy and the edges actually browned and had the crisp crunchy texture I love. Most gluten free items lack the texture I remember. I recommend this product and humbly ask “please don’t fix these crusts for any reason, they are not broken. Thank you for working to provide a great product.

Ingrid Shanklin

Love!

5.0 rating
May 28, 2020

I absolutely love the gluten free pie shells anyone that has them say how good the crust is

Trudy Egan

Crusty Browned Perfect Pie Crust is Hard to Find - This was it!

5.0 rating
February 19, 2020

Used Wholley Gluten Free Pie Crust for a Chicken Pot Pie. I prebaked the bottom crust for 12 minutes to brown then filled with prepared chicken pot pie ingredients. I think I let the pie crust thaw for too long as it was hard to separate from foil pan for the top crust, but I used a spatula to upside down the dough onto the pie. Had to piece together a bit but covered well. As a long time gluten free person, I can tell you it’s hard to find tasty pie crusts. I have used Bob’s do it yourself pie crust which is a lot of work. This is easy and the results are the same if not better. I did bake for much longer than instructed but just let the browning of the crust guide me. It was crispy and delicious. I can’t wait to make a lemon meringue – my favorite, and I know this is the crust to do it with.

Casey Denhoff

Have used Traditional, Wheat, and Gluten-Free Pie Shells

4.0 rating
February 11, 2020

The traditional and wheat work perfectly. I’ve used them for a few different pies, and people raved. Both came out flaky and delicious – 5 stars. The gluten-free pie shell tastes good, but was more finicky. It was definitely under-baked per the instructions and even with a couple extra minutes of baking. With the right timing though, it could be good – 3.5 stars.

Alisa Fleming

About Author

Alisa is the founder of GoDairyFree.org, Food Editor for Allergic Living magazine, and author of the best-selling dairy-free book, Go Dairy Free: The Guide and Cookbook for Milk Allergies, Lactose Intolerance, and Casein-Free Living, and the new cookbook, Eat Dairy Free: Your Essential Cookbook for Everyday Meals, Snacks, and Sweets. Alisa is also a professional recipe creator and product ambassador for the natural food industry.

24 Comments

  1. I tried your pie crust for the first time to make pumpkin pie and I was a bit worried after reading some of the reviews. At first, I thought about pre-baking the pie crusts so they would be brown. I took them out of the freezer to thaw, but then went ahead and poured the pumpkin pie mixture into them and put them in the oven to bake. They came out nicely browned and looked perfect. Then without even trying them, I took them to a family get together/holiday dinner and served them with whipped cream. I could not believe how good the crusts tasted. I was worried that they would be too “hard” or too “chewy” but they were not. Even though I knew they were gluten free, the flavor was not GF type like I have experienced before. I really do recommend these pie crusts and look forward to trying the pizza dough next. I am tired of thin GF pizza and want to try something resembling hand tossed or as I like to say, a pizza with a handle(crust). My pumpkin pie came out great and I WILL be using this brand of frozen pie crust again.

  2. Carol Morgan on

    I was not too impressed with your pie crusts. They never browned, as some of the reviews said. They where very hard and not at all flaky. I was very disappointed. Also the pie shells need to be bigger in size, 9 inches will not except most recipes and I have to waste the rest of the batter. I am not having any success finding a good recipe for a great crust. Sorry to be so negative but they are not very good and some improvement needs to be done before I buy them again. I was really embarrassed when I took it for dessert on Thanksgiving. Before I went Gluten Free I was known for my flaky crusts and delicious pies.

  3. In my opinion, the Wholly Wholesome gluten free pie crusts are actually better than regular ones, and my daughter, who doesn’t have to eat them, buys them for herself, instead of the regular ones! I grew up eating lard pie crusts, and they remind me of those. I do not understand the reviewer who said they won’t brown. I have to cover mine to keep them from over-browning. Mine were thawed when used so perhaps that is a factor. My only quibble is that they are too small for many recipes, and I end up throwing out batter or running it over. They need to be at least 10 inches in size, because the edges tend to flatten, making this problem worse.

    • Hi Anne, thanks so much for sharing your opinion on these, too! I have to agree, they are often too small. I’ve run into that problem, too! It would be nice if they made another size, too.

  4. Pat O'Connor on

    I have purchased 4 packages of the Pizza Dough and love it!!! I made 2 pizzas, and today I used 1 for Cinnamon Rolls!! They came out Awesome!!! I used Wholesome Sweeteners Coconut Palm Sugar and Tropical Plantation Coconut Oil, along with Cinnamon & Crushed Walnuts. I made them for my husband, but had to “test” them, AMAZING!

  5. Very impressed!!!! We just tried the 9′ pie shells and are thrilled by this quality product. My wife has problems with not only gluten, but also corn and oatmeal. I am soy intolerant. These pie shells are perfect or both of us and are superier to anything we have tried before. I love pies and had almost given up on finding something we could both eat and enjoy. Anyone who has been gluten free for over ten years will truly appreciate the progress that has been made in creating products that are both safe and tasty. Thanks so much!!!!

  6. Teresa Behrmann on

    I’m hoping these are as good as the reviews are saying they are. I was diagnosed with Celiac disease 3 years ago and have had to go strictly on a gluten free diet. Everything we try is by trial and error. Most of the things we have tried are rather good. I have missed being able to eat pies at holidays. My son wants to try making a dutch apple pie this year, because that’s my favorite. So fingers crossed this will give us thumbs up!

  7. I’d like to know (and sadly don t have time to experiment) if baking ahead a couple of days is a bad idea with these shells. I’ve found GF items really need to be super fresh to taste good, and keep the right texture. I want to bake pies today (Tuesday) to have Wednesday and Thursday. Anyone tried that yet?

  8. Janice Sawyer on

    I’m sorry to say, but the gf pie crust was tough and flavorless. I won’t be buying it again. I threw out the second crust without even cooking it.

    • That’s so odd Janice. We didn’t find it flavorless and it actually hesitated to bake up – wasn’t tough at all. I hope they haven’t changed the formula! Thanks for sharing your review / feedback.

  9. AWESOME! Just doesn’t cover it. I have been looking so long for a GF, dairy free, egg, soy, but, corn and additive free crust and this is it!!! I have used it for chicken pot pies, pumpkin pies, etc. The cook beautifully and taste even better! Can’t say enough good things about these. They are the best out there! Now, let’s get them in all the stores so I dont have to drive 20 miles to find them!

      • Hi, I tried these pie crusts for a non-dessert dish, not suspecting that they are sweet. It spoiled my savory pie. It would be very helpful if they would post “Sweet” on the crusts. Even if I were making a dessert pie, it still would help me to adjust the sugar content of the filling accordingly.

        • Hi Ann, this is very strange – they have less than 1g of sugar per serving in their pie shells, and they do state that they are good for savories like quiche. I’ve only used them with sweet pies to date, but appreciate your feedback on this!

  10. Just wanted to say thanks for the review! My mom got me some of pie crusts to try, and I was hesitant (for all the reasons you mention) to use them. But, I read your review and I was satisfied. Baked them up tonight! They really were great, just as you described. Thanks!